The Art of Balancing Freedom and Responsibility: User-Generated Content Management Strategies

balancing freedom and responsibility
UPDATED April 19, 2024
Written By Laniel Arive

As the digital realm becomes less and less passive over time, user content has become a cornerstone of online interaction. From product reviews in online shops to posts and comments on social media, user input has been fueling the lifelines of online platforms. Thus, investing in effective user-generated content moderation is only imperative to leverage UGC for positive outcomes.

User-generated content (UGC) refers to any material produced by online users, such as text, images, videos, and other multimodal content. The format of UGC usually depends on the nature of the platform. For instance, product reviews and testimonials are the primary UGC in online shopping sites, while images and videos are common in social media and live streaming platforms, respectively.

However, with about 5.35 billion Internet users across the globe, the amount of UGC is unprecedented, making it more difficult for digital platforms to keep the online world safe and squeaky clean. In short, the exponential growth of online data has added to the burden of UGC moderation solutions.

But what is UGC moderation?

UGC content moderation refers to screening and reviewing user-created content such as text, images, and videos, among others. It involves flagging and taking down potentially harmful content, which is the center of the ethical dilemma between freedom of speech and social responsibility.

Understanding User Freedom

man using phone

The merits of UGC campaigns in online platforms have birthed vast digital freedom. Users can freely share their thoughts, opinions, and ideas in the virtual world. While it is important for users to enjoy their internet freedom, platforms also leverage this to gain a competitive advantage over other platforms.

Here’s a quick rundown of the importance of user freedom that paves the way for UGC platforms:

  • Community Engagement

UGC fosters community engagement by encouraging users to actively share their insights, thoughts, and ideas through different digital channels. In the online business landscape, engaging customers in brand conversations is important to boost social media reach, interactions, comments, and shares. All in all, community engagement is the lifeblood of successful marketing campaigns and is the primary reason platforms cater to UGC.

  • Diverse Perspectives

UGC comes from different users from different social and cultural backgrounds. Thus, UGC platforms accommodate diverse perspectives in the online world, which is vital to make everyone feel valued and included.

For brands thriving in digital spaces, catering to diverse clientele is pivotal in pinning their brand to the global market map. In summary, UGC fuels companies’ goals of broadening their reach and guaranteeing business growth.

  • Authenticity

UGC is the driving force behind a platform’s authenticity. In fact, 86% of consumers are more likely to trust UGC, such as customer reviews and testimonials, than product endorsers or social media influencers.

Meanwhile, maintaining authenticity is important to continuously foster customer trust and ensure customer retention, loyalty, and revenue growth.

Challenges in User-Generated Content Platforms

stressed man with laptop

While UGC is crucial in sustaining digital platforms on the one hand, it grapples with a myriad of challenges on the other. These hurdles blossom from excessive digital freedom, which allows online platforms to become breeding grounds for harmful and fraudulent activities.

Here are some challenges in UGC-driven platforms:

  • Content Volume

The biggest challenge for user-generated content companies is managing the vast amounts of user-created content. As the number of internet users continues to balloon, screening them to uphold online safety becomes increasingly difficult.

  • Misinformation

Another challenge when user freedom remains unguarded is the proliferation of misinformation and disinformation. With everything just one click away on the internet, users can easily manipulate or fabricate content to deceive others. For online brands, the spread of misinformation, such as fake reviews and poor-quality testimonials, can pose huge reputational risks to them.

  • Offensive Content

Besides fake information, unpoliced digital freedom may also cause identity thieves, online scammers, and internet trolls to operate. They can spread inappropriate and harmful content such as hate speech, discrimination, spam, sexual imagery, and other disturbing materials.

  • Privacy and Legal Issues

Companies often grapple with privacy and legal issues when dealing with UGC. Because user-submitted content is technically the property of users, companies need to navigate legalities involving user data privacy and copyright rules to avoid lawsuits and legal complexities.

Importance of Responsible Moderation

man holding ai tablet

Given the complications that the vast internet freedom comes with, we will now delve into how and why is content moderation important for user-generated campaigns.

User-generated content moderators are digital police who screen UGC to ensure compliance with platform standards and safety measures. Whether by training and developing an in-house moderation team or availing of UGC moderation outsourcing, content moderation is crucial in performing the following:

  • It upholds user safety by eliminating unwanted, poor-quality, and harmful content.
  • It ensures positive user experiences where users can only expect authentic, high-quality, and relevant online materials.
  • It guarantees healthy online interactions among platform members and visitors.
  • It protects and maintains a good brand reputation and boosts online presence by keeping the digital platforms safe and clean.
  • It strikes the delicate balance between the user’s freedom of speech and the digital platform’s social responsibility.

Summarily, poor implementation or the total absence of UGC moderation solutions can tarnish user experience, diminish customer trust, damage the brand’s reputation, and slow down the company’s drive to growth and success.

Strategies for Balancing Freedom and Responsibility

weighing scale

Inarguably, UGC moderation services are a necessity in today’s digital age rather than just a nice-to-have. However, employing content moderation strategies is more complex than it sounds. Thus, in discovering the art of balancing freedom of expression and social responsibility, it is important to take note of the following tips:

  • Employ Automated Moderation

To uphold free speech and social responsibility evenly, it is imperative to employ automated moderation solutions. These solutions include artificial intelligence (AI) technologies that enable digital platforms to handle massive amounts of online data at scale and in real-time. This is beneficial for ensuring online safety and users' active participation in the digital landscape.

  • Maximize Human Expertise

While a UGC moderation company may impose automated tools for scalable moderation solutions, the role of human content moderators remains invaluable. They should be the last line of defense in keeping online platforms safe.

AI tools can flag potentially harmful content and remove the obviously prohibited ones. However, in the cases of nuanced content, the qualitative judgment of content moderators is crucial. This is the best way to ensure accurate moderation outcomes and avoid infringing on the user's freedom of expression.

  • Implement Report Mechanisms

While UGC moderation service providers take the bigger part of the job, the community's participation is equally important. Their feedback reflects the effectiveness of moderation solutions, and they help flag prohibited content or track down accounts that spread such content. Thus, implementing report mechanisms must be put in place to gauge moderation performance and give users an outlet where they can appeal to potentially inaccurate moderation outcomes. Overall, this ensures that users are involved in content moderation.

Leveraging Technology for Effective UGC Moderation

robot and human hand

As mentioned, automated moderation is a big plus in upholding user freedom and safety at the same time. Automated moderation solutions include the use of AI tools, such as the following:

  • Natural Language Processing (NLP)

NLP allows computer systems to comprehend the depths of human speech. It analyzes human language in closely the same way as humans, allowing UGC moderation tools to flag harmful content by filtering through its text.

  • Machine Learning 

Machine learning mimics human intelligence. It refers to the AI’s capacity to analyze algorithms and recognize content patterns, enabling computer systems to detect potentially harmful and prohibited content. 

The combination of these AI tools took the UGC moderation game to a higher level, providing scalable, consistent, and reliable solutions. However, the robust development of technology cannot take over the content moderation alone. Human intervention remains essential to UGC moderation to formulate the perfect solution to balance free speech and responsibility.

Community Engagement and Education

group of people

Besides compelling automated and manual moderation, the effectiveness of UGC moderation solutions relies on community engagement and education. 

On the one hand, user education plays a critical role in promoting responsible content creation. It fosters a culture of self-regulation and self-management, reducing the prevalence of harmful content.

On the other hand, community engagement in reporting harmful, poor-quality, and unwanted content is essential in combating the proliferation of fake news, cybercrimes, graphic content, and other disturbing materials.

Here’s a quick rundown of how UGC content moderation can improve:

  • Reporting Mechanisms

Strict content moderation practices must include implementing reporting mechanisms. Users must be able to report unwanted and harmful content that they encounter on the platform. Report buttons and links must be easy to use and accessible.

  • Feedback on Reports

Besides convenient report buttons, digital platforms must also provide feedback on user reports that they receive. This assures users that their actions matter, and feedback also helps users understand content moderation better.

  • Educational Resources

Online businesses, social media sites, dating apps, and other platforms must make their community guidelines and standards, content moderation rules, and processes available to the public. This helps users understand how to behave on the platform on the one hand and promotes transparency on the other.

  • Regular Updates

UGC content moderation is an ever-changing endeavor, and users are entitled to know about changes in moderation policies to help them align their contributions with platform rules and standards.

Perfecting Content Moderation Strategies with the Right Outsourcing Partner

robot and human hand

The perfect content moderation strategy has yet to be found. Due to robust technological development, the future remains a mystery. However, at the moment, the ideal UGC moderation solution to balance user freedom and social responsibility entails human expertise and AI assistance.

On the one hand, AI technologies, such as NLP and machine learning algorithms, handle the massive volumes of content in digital spaces. They enable sifting through online data in real-time and at scale, curbing the proliferation of harmful content. In short, AI is pivotal in guaranteeing responsible moderation.

On the other hand, human content moderators review the materials flagged by AI tools and decide on the best course of action. Thus, they are crucial in ensuring that the moderation outcomes are reliable and accurate to avoid tarnishing the vibrant freedom of expression users must enjoy.

Chekkee offers optimal UGC moderation service, anchored on the combination of manual and technological prowess. We employ cutting-edge technologies and trained professionals to ensure the accuracy, reliability, and efficiency of your content moderation solutions.

In mastering the art of balancing user freedom and social responsibility, Chekkee is just around the corner to help. Contact us today!

Share this Post

Recent Post
How Do Online Moderators Shape Digital Platforms?
Navigating the World of Online Moderators From hate speech and fake profiles to misinformation and
Written by Laniel Arive
What is Social Media Moderator and What Do They Do?
Understanding What is a Social Media Moderator and Its Importance Imagine scrolling through your favorite
Written by John Calongcagon
How Social Media Content Moderators Tackle Online Challenges
Navigating Online Challenges: Social Media Content Moderators’ Tactics Social media is a powerful tool for
Written by Alyssa Maano

Let’s Discuss your Project


Want to talk about Your Project?

Fill up the form and receive updates on your email.

Get Started

How can we help
I would like to inquire about career opportunities

    Copyright © 2023. All Rights Reserved